| pos. | code | crew stroke | number | finish | qualification | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | SHEN | Friends of Shenendehowa Crew, Inc. | 2 | 04:57.85 | (1) | FA |
| Jacob Manny | ||||||
| 2. | ONRA | Oak Neck Rowing Academy A | 1 | 05:02.16 | (2) | FA |
| Robert Dring | +4.31 | |||||
| 3. | RAR | RowAmerica Rye | 3 | 05:02.64 | (3) | FA |
| George Dolce | +4.79 | |||||
| 4. | ONRA | Oak Neck Rowing Academy B | 11 | 05:09.20 | (4) | FA |
| Bradyn Brogan | +11.35 | |||||
| 5. | LIRC | Long Island Rowing Club, Inc. | 6 | 05:14.85 | (5) | FA |
| Woodford Pollach | +17.00 | |||||
| 6. | FP | Fordham Preparatory School | 8 | 05:19.07 | (6) | FA |
| Desta Porras-Tibebe | +21.22 | |||||
| 7. | Niskayuna | Niskayuna Rowing | 5 | 05:27.42 | (7) | FA |
| Kevin Tully | +29.57 | |||||
| 8. | MHS | Manhasset Crew | 10 | 05:28.28 | (8) | FA |
| Arjun Saini | +30.43 | |||||
| 9. | BRC | Brighton Rowing Club, Inc. | 7 | 05:37.16 | (9) | FA |
| James Daley | +39.31 | |||||
| 10. | PJRC | Friends of Port Jefferson Rowing Club | 9 | 05:42.18 | (10) | |
| Thomas Hyams | +44.33 | |||||
| ARC | O.A.R.S., Inc. dba Albany Rowing Center | 4 | did not start | |||
| Zach Gornstein | ||||||